8 Best Medical Alert Systems of 2022

Medical alert systems provide fast, easy access to emergency help. They're particularly important for people who live alone and are older than 65—the milestone age when the risk of heart attack, stroke, dementia, and falls starts to increase significantly.^1,2,3,4

All medical alert devices include a wearable help button, and some also include GPS tracking and automatic fall detection for extra protection. These devices—also called personalized emergency response systems (PERS)—share a lot of features from brand to brand.

To help you choose the right medical alert, we reviewed the differences between each and conducted hands-on testing. Only the most reliable and user-friendly brands made it onto our best medical alert systems list. We've named Bay Alarm Medical the best-of-the-best, but we encourage you to read through the entire list to find your perfect match.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and protect your home, loved ones, and belongings.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and learn how to protect your home, your loved ones, and your belongings.

Many other brands rely on just GPS data for location tracking. Because there’s more than one technology at work in the Mini Guardian, it’s more likely to transmit an accurate location to caregivers or the monitoring center.

The Mini Guardian comes with a lanyard and belt clip, and its battery lasts up to five days. You can add a built-in fall-detection sensor to this mobile medical alert system for an extra $10 a month.

We also like the MyGuardian app and online dashboard, which lets your loved ones and caregivers see where you’ve been and where you are now. You have full control over who gets this information.

Other medical alert companies have no caregiver portal, make you pay extra for one, or only give location information through text.

MyGuardian also lets your loved ones keep an eye on the Mini Guardian’s battery or pay your monthly bill.

Learn more in our full review of Medical Guardian or check out our Medical Guardian product guide.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and learn how to protect your home, loved ones, and belongings.

The more sensors in a device, the more accurately it detects falls. Out of more than 75 devices we considered, only three had dual fall-detection sensors.

Lifeline thoroughly explains how its fall-detection devices work—including the limitations of those devices—on its website, offering a level of transparency above and beyond any other brand. Lifeline also seems to take fall detection a little more seriously with data analytics and testing.

Our main criticism of Lifeline is its price. Yes, it’s often worth paying more for better tech and service, especially for something as serious as a medical alert system. But we don’t like the extra fees that come with setting up or canceling a Lifeline account.

Budget for a $50 activation fee for the AutoAlert. If you decide to cancel, be prepared for a $50 restocking fee. 

Learn more about AutoAlert on the Lifeline website or read our full Lifeline review. Or, take a look at how Lifeline compares to one of our other top brands in our head-to-head review: Lifeline vs. Medical Guardian.

LifeFone monitors all system batteries and sends you replacement devices when the battery gets low (which takes about five years). The wearable pendants can double as a phone receiver, allowing you to answer all incoming calls anywhere in the house or yard, and the base units monitor indoor temperature.

LifeFone’s extra features provide a fail-safe for people at risk of passing out or being unable to push the help button.

• Fall detection starts at $5/month
• Activity assurance for $6/month
• Daily check-in calls for $19/month

Learn more in our full LifeFone review.

Read our full review of the most affordable medical alert systems for more details.

All MobileHelp subscribers have access to a telehealth service called MDLive. MDLive allows you to speak to a doctor on demand. They can prescribe common medications, ensuring a small problem doesn’t turn into a big deal. You don’t pay a co-pay or even have to verify your insurance.

Learn more in our full review of MobileHelp.

We also like that Aloe Care sells extra motion sensors that offer a second layer of protection. The sensors learn your typical routine and alert caregivers if you aren’t active at your usual times.

Aloe Care does have a few kinks to work out like the base station backup battery—it lasts just six hours, which is way behind the 32-hour life of many other brands.

In addition, Aloe Care’s wearable button has the smallest range we encountered, so you can’t really wear it into the yard. You’ll have to grab the mobile unit on your way out.

Learn more about our testing experience in our full review of Aloe Care Health. Or compare it to another voice-activated system in our GetSafe vs. Aloe Care Health head-to-head review.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and learn how to protect your home, loved ones, and belongings.

Lifenet also offers a free lifetime warranty on all equipment. Many other companies will charge you for the price of lost or damaged equipment—which can easily cost over $300—or make you pay for an extended warranty.

We also like these Lifenet policies and services:

• Prorated refunds
• Batteries monitored and replaced by the company
• Affordable spouse coverage ($3.99/mo.)

Lifenet sells two equipment packages: Home and Garden, and Home and Away.

Home and Garden is an in-home system. Its base unit connects to a landline, and you wear a wristband with a button on it. The button works within about 1,000 feet of the base station so you can go out into the yard and know that help is still a push away. It costs $29.95 per month, and you can add wall buttons for an additional $2.49 a month each.

Home and Away is a wearable medical alert device. It includes a help button, a speaker, and a microphone so you don’t have to stay near a base station to ask for help. This waterproof device also detects falls and features GPS technology so helpers can know where to find you if you get lost. The Home and Away costs $49.95 per month.

The only extra service offered by Lifenet is a “daily assurance” check-in. A Lifenet representative speaks to you every day, and they send help if you don’t respond.

We considered more than 75 products across nearly 30 brands. Here are a few that didn’t quite make the cut.

Medical Care Alert offers similar equipment to Bay Alarm but costs around $5 to $7 more each month. We also found its website a little confusing because there’s no way to easily see its full product lineup.

It’s worth mentioning that Medical Care Alert used to offer a fall detection device with the holy trinity of sensors: an accelerometer, gyroscope, and magnetometer. This product was discontinued because it relied on the now-defunct 3G cellular network.

If Medical Care Alert releases this device again with 4G or 5G cellular service, we’ll sit up and pay attention. But for now, we think other brands offer better value. 

We’re keeping a close eye on Medical Alert because it achieved “runner-up” status in key categories. For example, Medical Alert’s fall detection system includes two sensors, and its basic in-home system costs the same as MobileHelp’s. We also found Medical Alert’s representatives to be the most knowledgeable, which can make a big difference when shopping around.

We’ll offer more insights about how Medical Alert compares to our other top brands after hands-on testing.  

Learn more in our full Medical Alert review.

If you have an ADT home security system, you can get a discount on its in-home and on-the-go medical alert packages. Otherwise, the cost of an ADT Medical Alert system is a bit high for what you get. It starts at $29.99/month for a landline system without fall detection.

We also weren’t impressed by the signal range for the in-home systems: 300 feet for the Basic and 600 feet for the Plus.

That said, ADT Medical Alert is one of the few systems you can snag with a price lock guarantee—definitely a big deal if you rely on limited income like social security.

Learn more about in our full review of ADT Medical Alert.

LifeStation deserves a shout-out as the only other medical alert company besides Lifeline to combine an accelerometer and a barometric sensor in its fall detection device. LifeStation’s basic in-home package starts at $32 per month, but GPS tracking, fall detection, wall buttons, spouse coverage, and a warranty all add to the monthly fee.

Learn more in our full review of LifeStation.

The Lively Wearable 2 has been discontinued, but it was never our favorite medical alert device to begin with since it didn't include a built-in speaker—you needed a smartphone nearby for it to be useful

The Lively Mobile Plus is still available. There’s really nothing wrong with this product—we just prefer the extra tracking technology in the Medical Guardian Mini Guardian and the superior fall detection technology in the Lifeline AutoAlert.

Lively also partnered up with some big names in the tech industry. It's now the professional monitoring option for Apple Watches and Alexa Together. Although it can get pricey, Lively's concierge services are worth looking into.

Learn more in our full Lively review. 

Our hearts definitely went pitter-patter when we saw this gorgeous medical alert watch. The BellPal doesn’t look like a medical alert device at all, but it includes GPS tracking, fall detection, and an SOS button. Like the Lively Wearable 2, BellPal only works when it’s close to a smartphone.

We were also bummed to see that you have to take this watch to a jeweler every four to six months to replace the battery. We know “replace battery” would end up on our to-do list for weeks. That’s why many other companies just send you a new wearable device instead of asking you to do it yourself.

BellPal costs about $200 up front. Monitoring is provided through BlueStar SeniorTech starting at around $20 a month.

The WellBe was in the running for our “Best extra features” category. We think this could be the medical alarm system of the future once digital natives start to age in place. It’s a smart speaker with a special focus on health and wellness and pairs with an optional medical alert watch by the same name.

You can talk to it by saying, “OK WellBe” and then asking, for example, a medical question. WellBe can also be programmed to remind you to take your medications, to refill prescriptions, or to get ready for an upcoming appointment. It also works like a “normal” speaker by playing music, audio books, or the news.

The smartwatch doubles as a GPS tracker, health and fitness tracker, and help button. Caregivers can also keep track of your health through the app.

As cool as it is, we’re just not sure it’s the right system for everyone. You do need to be a bit tech savvy (or know someone who is) to take full advantage of it. Check it out if you already love chatting with your Amazon Echo.

Life Alert is an industry pioneer famous for its TV commercials, but it hasn’t moved its sales and marketing into the 21st century. There’s almost no information about the system online.

We called to discover the cost of Life Alert. It’s by far the most expensive medical alarm system on the market, with monitoring prices starting at nearly $50/month. The minimum activation fee is around $95. The price significantly increases if you add a GPS button, and there’s no automatic fall detection option at all.

Learn more in our full Life Alert review or check out our recommended Life Alert alternatives.

QMedic offers a cellular in-home system and a mobile GPS button. This company lost our interest once we found out it doesn’t offer any fall detection at all. It’s also the only company we found that requires a full year of payment up front.

FastHelp is not a monitored medical alert system, so we don’t recommend it for most situations.

Because it always calls 911 directly, you may get fined for false alarms. The 911 dispatchers and emergency responders also won’t have your medical history, lockbox code, or emergency contacts on file. In contrast, monitored systems retain this information and relay it to the emergency service for fast, accurate, and safe help.

The main advantage of FastHelp is that you only pay a one-time equipment fee. Since there’s no emergency monitoring, there are no monthly fees.

Learn more in our full FastHelp review.

We like Bay Alarm Medical best overall because it covers all the bases at a competitive price. But every person and situation is a little different, so you might prefer the price, tech, or policies of another company. The key is to find a device that makes you feel confident and independent.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and learn how to protect your home, your loved ones, and your belongings.

Read answers to more senior safety FAQs.

• 76 products considered
• 44 data points compared
• 7 products tested
• 2 weeks of product research

To prepare our medical alert system review, we compared each product’s technical specifications, talked to brand representatives, spoke with users, interviewed our advisory board member Sally Russell (MN, CMSRN, CNE, Health Expert and Educator), read scientific papers about the latest fall detection technology, and tested products hands-on.

Our proprietary weighted ranking system focuses on these categories:

• In-home tech specs and costs
• In-home equipment options
• Mobile device specs and costs
• Caregiving features
• Hands-on testing performance
• Company policies and attributes 

We compared each medical alert company's lowest monthly cost for an in-home cellular system. We didn't compare landline prices, because some companies don't offer landline-compatible equipment. However, we did take into consideration whether a landline option was offered. 

We also compared the lowest equipment fees, regardless of whether it was available as a landline or cellular system. Rounding out the in-home cost comparison was our analysis of hidden or extra fees, such as activation or installation fees.

We also considered backup battery life, maximum signal range, and more. And we investigated whether each company monitors and replaces their help button batteries for free.

We prefer seeing more equipment options since this allows people to make custom packages that suit their needs. We also looked at the cost of each option, preferring one-time fees over monthly fees for long-term affordability.

Some of the in-home equipment options we evaluated included fall detection, voice activation, wall buttons, jewelry pendants, and accessories like a lockbox or Vial of Life.

Because mobile devices often feature more technology than in-home devices, we scored them separately. 

For this category, we considered the lowest equipment costs and monthly costs, plus the maximum battery life. We preferred standalone devices that aren't dependent on a smartphone, and we liked seeing more than one wear option (such as a belt clip).

We also compared the number and type of fall detection sensors (tri-axial accelerometers, barometric pressure sensors, magnetometers, and gyroscope)  and location technologies (GPS, Wi-Fi, and 4G). 

Caregiving features were also considered in our medical alert rankings but given less weight than other categories because medical alert systems still work without these features. 

We looked for smartphone apps or online portals geared toward caregivers and considered the cost of these tools. We preferred systems with location tracking and battery alerts on the app, plus medication reminders and inactivity alerts.

We were able to test products from Bay Alarm Medical, GetSafe, and Aloe Care for this review, giving us extra insight into how each medical alert device performs in real-world situations.

For example, we placed multiple test calls to the professional monitoring centers to evaluate audio quality, answer speed, and ease of use. We also tested mobile medical alerts' GPS location accuracy, battery life, and caregiver app ease of use.

Finally, we compared each medical alert brand across 13 policies and attributes. For example, we considered warranties and trial periods, price lock guarantees, the cost of spouse coverage, cancellation penalties, and whether the monitoring center is Five Diamond certified. 

Learn more about our methodology.

Contributing author: Rebecca Edwards

• How to Talk to Your Parents about a Medical Alert System
• 10 Ways to Upgrade Your Home for an Older Family Member
• GPS Trackers for People with Dementia
• Best Safety Devices for Seniors
• Best Senior Smartwatches and Wearables

1. National Council on Aging, "Get the Facts on Falls Prevention," July 21, 2022. Accessed November 7, 2022.
2. Memorial Hermann Heart & Vascular Institute, "Heart Disease and Age." Accessed November 7, 2022.
3. Margaret Kelly-Hayes, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, "Influence of Age and Health Behaviors on Stroke Risk: Lessons from Longitudinal Studies," October 2011. Accessed November 7, 2022.
4. Alzheimer's Society, "Risk Factors: Who Gets Alzheimer's Disease?" Accessed November 7, 2022.
5. Lifeline, “Automatic Fall Detection.” Accessed November 7, 2022. 
6. Judy A. Stevens, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (CDC), “Nonfatal Bathroom Injuries Among Persons Aged ≥15 Years --- United States, 2008,” June 10, 2011. Accessed November 7, 2022.